Fujitsu crew had ‘unrestricted and unauditable’ a long way flung entry to Post Office department programs
Fujitsu engineers would possibly perchance perchance perchance fabricate adjustments to Post Office department accounts with out anybody gleaming
- Karl Flinders,Chief reporter and senior editor EMEA
Printed: 11 Will also merely 2023 10:00
Fujitsu had no regulate over crew in a single amongst its tech enhance teams accessing Post Office department accounts remotely to fabricate adjustments which would possibly perchance perchance perchance be hidden from subpostmasters.
Whereas it changed into as soon as already published that a long way flung entry changed into as soon as that it’s seemingly you’ll perchance perchance furthermore accept as true with, the dearth of regulate of this entry, published sooner or later of a Post Office Horizon scandal public inquiry hearing, sheds extra light on Fujitsu’s lax practices supporting its error-inclined system.
The Post Office Horizon scandal public inquiry heard that crew working at Fujitsu’s Utility Give a snatch to Centre (SCC), which provides third-line tech enhance to Post Office branches, had “unrestricted and unauditable” a long way flung entry to department accounts.
Horizon machine changed into as soon as launched in 1999 to exchange primarily manual accounting practices. On the foundation from ICL, earlier than its acquisition by Fujitsu, the IT system changed into as soon as rolled out to hundreds of Post Office branches, but its introduction resulted in a surprising extend in subpostmasters reporting unexplained shortfalls of their accounts, for which they were blamed.
A total bunch were prosecuted, with some sent to penal complex, and hundreds misplaced ample sums of money, with many going bankrupt. In entire, 86 mature subpostmasters ought up to now had wrongful convictions for fraud and theft overturned.
The existence of unrestricted and unauditable entry by Fujitsu crew to accounts would receive called into request any accusation that unexplained losses were attributable to subpostmaster error or theft.
Stephen Parker, a mature SCC supervisor, faced the final public inquiry in its contemporary half, which is investigating the operation of the controversial Horizon system. All over questioning, he admitted that regulate of SCC crew remotely accessing department programs relied on them being steady and following the entry protection, with no policing of their activity.
Post Office denial
For years, the Post Office, under strain over allegations the Horizon system errors were causing accounting shortfalls, denied that a long way flung entry to department accounts changed into as soon as that it’s seemingly you’ll perchance perchance furthermore accept as true with. In 2015, in written proof to the BIS Select Committee Inquiry of 2015, the Post Office stated: “There is no longer a functionality in Horizon for both a department, Post Office or Fujitsu to edit, manipulate or take away transaction records as soon because it has been recorded in a department’s accounts.” The Post Office finest admitted it changed into as soon as in actual fact that it’s seemingly you’ll perchance perchance furthermore accept as true with when it changed into as soon as left with no resolution, sooner or later of a Excessive Court docket case in 2019.
All over basically the most modern public inquiry hearing this week (10 Will also merely 2023), an operations manual from 2001 changed into as soon as examined. It acknowledged: “SSC has entry to the dwell system, which is ready to be old to appropriate records on the system when this has been corrupted by some potential.”
The inquiry heard that Fujitsu had a process in situation for crew to fabricate what were is named Operational Correction Requests (OCRs), which they would total earlier than remotely accessing dwell programs to fabricate adjustments. OCRs receive a process linked to them which involves that after adjustments are made there desires to be at the least two of us from SSC eager, known a “four eyes” diagram.
Nonetheless there changed into as soon as no policing of entry and its appropriate use relied on of us sticking to the process. Parker stated that to this point as he remembers, this diagram changed into as soon as linked to adjustments that can perchance perchance receive a financial affect on subpostmaster accounts. “It changed into as soon as enforced finest by process,” he stated. “This implies all people changed into as soon as awake that this changed into as soon as the requirement and on every occasion an OCR changed into as soon as accredited then they knew of the [process] they desired to attain.”
Jason Beer, Horizon Inquiry barrister, stated: “Folk are attentive to the velocity limit – that doesn’t indicate they repeatedly abide by it, does it?”
Parker stated: “I accept as true with you, but I’m no longer attentive to any cases that participants of the SSC didn’t abide by that rule.”
Nonetheless when asked whether or no longer there changed into as soon as an audit or monitoring to establish if of us accessed the dwell atmosphere exterior of the system exterior of the OCR policies, Parker admitted that “by some means they were trusting [people] to coach the process”.
Parker, who worked at SCC for 22 years, didn’t recall any audit of whether or no longer entry to the dwell estate to appropriate or swap financial records occurred. All around the hearing, it also emerged that SCC crew would possibly perchance perchance perchance fabricate adjustments to department accounts with out leaving a digital signature, leaving the subpostmaster of the department within the shadowy.
He admitted that any member of the SSC would possibly perchance perchance perchance fabricate adjustments with none one’s records. “Nonetheless I’m no longer attentive to that ever going down, and the nature of the of us within SSC (experienced technicians) potential the potentialities of anyone doing that with out anyone else realising there changed into as soon as one thing going on are practically nil.”
Outdated subpostmaster Michael Rudkin is sure he changed into as soon as singled out by the Post Office for asking principal questions about a long way flung entry to Horizon. In August 2008, when he changed into as soon as chairman of the negotiating committee of the Federation of Subpostmasters, Rudkin visited a Fujitsu expertise centre as half of a working neighborhood taking a watch at how to present a snatch to bureau de swap processes. All over his discuss over with, a Fujitsu worker demonstrated how he would possibly perchance perchance perchance fabricate adjustments to subpostmaster department accounts remotely, with out the subpostmasters gleaming.
Rudkin’s ride changed into as soon as confirmed in 2015 by mature Fujitsu engineer Richard Roll. After contacting Alan Batesthe mature subpostmaster who led the combat for justice for subpostmasters, Roll blew the whistle on a long way flung entry.
In 2009, Pc Weeklyprinted an investigation into the complications experienced by seven subpostmasters who were the usage of Horizon. The Post Office suggested every of them that nobody else changed into as soon as experiencing complications and lined up the computer errors. It’s a usual grievance of subpostmasters that the helpdesk didn’t attend them investigate unexplained accounting shortfalls.
Read more on IT for retail and logistics
Extra Post Office machine-linked convictions overturned takes entire to 86
By: Karl Flinders
CCRC says ‘door open’ for more reviews of subpostmaster convictions
By: Karl Flinders
Subpostmaster demands names of Post Office executives who crushed him to suffocate truth
By: Karl Flinders
IT worker proof reveals a poisonous Post Office IT helpdesk that discriminated in opposition to subpostmasters
By: Karl Flinders